Washington Nationals: Comparing Pitchers in the National League East
As the Washington Nationals approach the trade deadline, the pretenders have been separated from the contenders in the National League East.
In spring training, four of the five National League East teams were thought to be in contention for a playoff spot. However, as the season has progressed, it is now a three-team race.
The Miami Marlins are who everyone thought they were, namely a young team destined to linger at the bottom of the division until their young prospects come of age. And despite their General Manager’s boasting before the year began, the New York Mets have the look of a team that needs to do some serious rebuilding to get out of a two and a half year funk that has seen them post an anemic .453 winning percentage.
With roughly 40% of the season left to play, the front-running Atlanta Braves and the contending Washington Nationals and Philadelphia Phillies are left with hopes of playing post-season baseball in 2019. In the first part of a two-part series, we’ll look at how the team’s stack up against each other. Today, we examine the strengths and weaknesses of the teams’ pitchers and catchers.
STARTING PITCHING
If the Nationals are to be one of the five National League teams playing in October, it will likely be due to their superb starting pitching staff. With four starting pitchers among the National League’s top 20 in Wins Above Replacement, the Nats will go as far as their rotation will take them.
Max Scherzer (NL leading 5.5 WAR) gives the Nats a legitimate Cy Young Award contender, if not favorite, at the top of the rotation. Most teams would be overjoyed to have the Nats’ second and third starters, Stephen Strasburg (3.6 WAR) and Patrick Corbin (3.1 WAR), at the top of theirs.
After a rocky beginning to the season, Washington’s fourth starter Anibal Sanchez has turned his year around and has posted a respectable 6-6 record and 3.80 ERA to date. While fifth starter candidates Erick Fedde and Austin Voth have been inconsistent, they’ve both shown flashes of talent that might make them viable options at the bottom of Washington’s rotation.
The first-place Braves’ have uncovered a gem in rookie hurler Mike Soroka, whose 10-2 record and 2.46 ERA put him in the discussion for the National League Cy Young Award as well as the Circuit’s Rookie of the Year competition. Slender left-hander Max Fried has won 10 games for the Braves; recent acquisition Dallas Keuchel is a reliable veteran with playoff experience; Julio Teheran has allowed only three earned runs in 17.2 innings over his last three starts. The downside for Atlanta’s starting staff has been the inconsistent performance of hard-throwing right-handers Mike Foltynewicz (2-5, 6.37 ERA) and Kevin Gausman (3-5, 5.71 ERA) so far in 2019.
For the Phillies, ace Aaron Nola has been strong again in 2019 (8-2, 3.77 ERA) but the rest of the rotation has been suspect at best. Veteran Jake Arrieta has been limited by a lingering shoulder injury in 2019, and his 1.449 WHIP is the worst mark he’s posted since 2011 while playing for the Baltimore Orioles. Zach Eflin started the season strong, allowing two or more earned runs in only two of his first 14 starts, but he’s been awful over his last four (22 earned runs and seven home runs in only 20 innings pitched). The Phils’ starting staff’s 4.59 ERA is the worst among NL East contenders.
Grading the rotations:
Washington: A, Maybe baseball’s best starting crew.
Atlanta: B, The emergence of Sorotka has been crucial.
Philadelphia C-, Can anyone other than Nola be counted on?
RELIEF PITCHING
The Nationals’ relief crew has performed at historically bad levels for most of the 2019 season, and while there have been improvements made, the bullpen is a serious area of need for Washington. The Nationals do have the division’s best closer in left-hander Sean Doolittle, but his 42 hits allowed in 41 innings pitched so far is a career-worst mark. The team’s off-season acquisitions of the since waived Trevor Rosenthal, current minor leaguer Kyle Barraclough and to date inconsistent Tony Sipp have been disasters.
Young Tanner Rainey has shown flashes of brilliance (13.7 SO/9) but has been wildly inconsistent, as has the seemingly overworked Wander Suero. Veteran Fernando Rodney still throws hard and has a solid mound presence, but can he be relied on to bridge the gap to Doolittle?
While not bringing back memories of the Cincinnati Reds’ nasty boys from the late ’80s, Atlanta’s bullpen has been the best of the three teams so far. Closer Luke Jackson has had his hiccups (like Friday’s blown save courtesy of Victor Robles’s two-out home run) but has been most effective at the back end of the Braves bullpen.
After struggling mightily while playing for the Mets in 2018, Anthony Swarzak has been tremendous so far in Atlanta (0.44 ERA, 10.2 SO/9), as has unheralded Jacob Webb (4-0, 1.39 ERA). Southpaws Sean Newcomb and well-traveled reliever Jerry Blevins have given manager Brian Snitker decent options to take on dangerous left-handed hitters, and hard-throwing Chad Sobotka (11.0 SO/9) has battled inconsistency but can dominate at times
Phillies’ closer Hector Neris throws extremely hard and has a splitter that can be virtually impossible to hit, but he’s home run prone (eight home runs allowed so far in 2019) and has melted down in the clutch on several occasions so this year. Lefties Jose Alvarez (0-2. 3.32 ERA) and Adam Morgan (3-3, 3.51 ERA) have been relatively effective out of manager Gabe Kapler’s bullpen so far. Hard-throwing right-hander Juan Nicasio has been a major disappointment (1.651 WHIP) and injuries to Seranthony Dominguez and free-agent acquisition David Robertson have hurt the Phils’ in terms of right-handed bullpen depth.
Grading the bullpens:
Atlanta: B Best in the division by default.
Philadelphia: C- There’ll be plenty of late-inning drama in Philly.
Washington: D Help wanted, and urgently needed.
CATCHERS
After getting anemic production from its starting catching crew in 2018, Washington traded for Yan Gomes and signed veteran free agent Kurt Suzuki before the 2019 season. The Gomes acquisition has been a disappointment, as the one-time All-Star struggles to hit above the Mendoza Line and has been less than effective at times defensively as well. As poor as the trade for Gomes has been so far, the decision to bring Suzuki back to Washington has been brilliant.
The well-respected veteran has hit 11 home runs and driven in 39 in part-time play so far and has worked well with the Nats’ pitching staff. Although some would like to see Suzuki in the lineup regularly, an argument can be made that manager Davey Martinez’s decision play the 35-year-old on a part-time basis has helped keep his production up.
The blue-collar pair who toil behind the plate in Atlanta may be short on flash, but they are solid in production. No-nonsense veteran Brian McCann has provided decent production (eight homers, 32 RBI) as the team’s primary catcher, and has been a dependable and steady presence behind the plate. Solidly built Tyler Flowers has allowed a league-leading 11 passed balls, but he has excellent power and provides adequate on-base skills as a hitter.
While the Phillies paid a high price to acquire All-Star catcher J.T. Realmuto from division rival Miami during the off-season, Realmuto has been relatively effective in his first year in Phils’ colors. His OPS+ of 96 is significantly below the career-high 128 marks he put up in 2018, but Realmuto remains a threat at the plate who is also a strong defensive backstop. The Phillies’ lack of an effective backup for Realmuto may be something the team needs to address to keep Realmuto from wearing down in the season’s final weeks.
Next. Greene + Dyson in DC?. dark
Grading the catchers:
Philadelphia: B Realmuto is solid but can he survive the workload?
Atlanta: B- Will steady and slow win the race?
Washington: C Better than in 2018, but average at best.