District on Deck makes their official 2024 MLB Free Agency predictions

The staff here at District on Deck has officially weighed in with our predictions for many of the big free agents around the baseball world.

San Diego Padres v Washington Nationals
San Diego Padres v Washington Nationals / Scott Taetsch/GettyImages

While free agency is officially open, no major moves have yet to be made by any teams except for the Los Angeles Angels, who have been busy. But before the Hot Stove really starts to heat up and players begin to move like nobody's business, the staff here at District On Deck decided to compile our free agency predictions to get everything on the record. With that being said, let's take a look at everyone's picks!

We couldn't do every single free agent, so we compiled a list of about 30 or so free agents to make our predictions as to where they will sign this offseason. Please note that these predictions are based on what we think will happen, not necessarily what we want to happen.

Each player that we chose will have a number next to them which represents the number of staff members that predicted that the player will sign with that team. I also will include framework for what a potential deal could look like next to their name as well, signifying an average of what we anticipate them signing for. Big shoutout to the team here at District On Deck, and we'll be keeping an eye on who got the most correct predictions by the end of it!


All Nationals additions by each staff member were underlined as well.

2024 District On Deck Staff Free Agency Predictions

Arthur Bobbitt @natsdegrom

Alex Bregman - Nationals - 6 years/$200M
Andrew Heaney - Nationals - 2 years/$21M
Anthony Santander - Nationals - 4 years/$110m
Blake Snell - Red Sox - 5 years/$140M
Carlos Estévez - Yankees - 2 years/$35M
Christian Walker - Yankees - 3 years/$45M
Clay Holmes - Red Sox - 3 years/$50M
Corbin Burnes - Orioles - 6 years/$230M
Frankie Montas - Angels - 2 years/$30M
Gleyber Torres - Mariners - 2 years/$16M
Ha-Seong Kim - Giants - 4 years/$70M
Jack Flaherty - Astros - 4 years/$90M
Jeff Hoffman - Phillies - 4 years/$45M
Joc Pederson - Pirates - 2 years/$35M
Juan Soto - Mets - 12 years/$700M
Jurickson Profar - Brewers - 3 years/$50M
Luis Severino - Mets - 3 years/$50M
Max Fried - Braves - 7 years/$130M
Nathan Eovaldi - Rangers - 3 years/$60M
Paul Goldschmidt - Diamondbacks - 1 year/$12M
Pete Alonso - Mets - 7 years/$200M
Roki Sasaki - Dodgers - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Dodgers - 4 years/$80M
Shane Bieber - Brewers - 2 years/$35M
Tanner Scott - Padres - 3 years/$40M
Teoscar Hernández - Dodgers - 4 years/$100M
Tyler O'Neill - Royals - 4 years/$55M
Walker Buehler - Nationals - 2 years/$22M
Willy Adames - Astros - 5 years/$120M
Yusei Kikuchi - Cubs - 3 years/$55M

Bennett Lehmann @DCBerk

Alex Bregman - Nationals - 6 years/$180M
Andrew Heaney - Blue Jays - 2 years/$26M
Anthony Santander - Blue Jays - 4 years/$120m
Blake Snell - Orioles - 5 years/$150M
Carlos Estévez - Phillies - 3 years/$39M
Christian Walker - Nationals - 3 years/$48M
Clay Holmes - Rangers - 3 years/$42M
Corbin Burnes - Mets - 7 years/$220M
Frankie Montas - Royals - 2 years/$26M
Gleyber Torres - Mariners - 3 years/$36M
Ha-Seong Kim - Yankees - 4 years/$48M
Jack Flaherty - Padres - 4 years/$80M
Jeff Hoffman - Padres - 4 years/$36M
Joc Pederson - Diamondbacks - 2 years/$36M
Juan Soto - Mets - 14 years/$600M
Jurickson Profar - Padres - 3 years/$50M
Luis Severino - Tigers - 3 years/$60M
Max Fried - Dodgers - 7 years/$130M
Nathan Eovaldi - Orioles - 3 years/$60M
Paul Goldschmidt - Astros - 1 year/$16M
Pete Alonso - Mariners - 7 years/$200M
Roki Sasaki - Padres - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Mets - 4 years/$84M
Shane Bieber - Astros - 2 years/$40M
Tanner Scott - Cubs - 3 years/$48M
Teoscar Hernández - Red Sox - 4 years/$96M
Tyler O'Neill - Tigers - 4 years/$60M
Walker Buehler - Nationals - 2 years/$28M
Willy Adames - Braves - 5 years/$125M
Yusei Kikuchi - Red Sox - 3 years/$55M

Brandon Little @branlittle58

Alex Bregman - Nationals - 5 years/$180M
Andrew Heaney - Orioles - 2 years/$15M
Anthony Santander - Nationals - 6 years/$120M
Blake Snell - Guardians - 5 years/$140M
Carlos Estévez - Phillies - 3 years/$35M
Christian Walker - Diamondbacks - 3 years/$60M
Clay Holmes - Brewers - 1 year/$8M
Corbin Burnes - Yankees - 6 years/$220M
Frankie Montas - Cubs - 3 years/$31M
Gleyber Torres - Blue Jays - 2 years/$20M
Ha-Seong Kim - Mariners - 3 years/$25M
Jack Flaherty - Tigers - 2 years/$50M
Jeff Hoffman - Yankees - 3 years/$25M
Joc Pederson - Astros - 1 year/$10M
Juan Soto - Dodgers - 14 years/$670M
Jurickson Profar - Rockies - 1 year/$15M
Luis Severino - Mets - 2 years/$30M
Max Fried - Braves - 7 years/$190M
Nathan Eovaldi - Orioles - 4 years/$100M
Paul Goldschmidt - Cardinals - 1 year/$6M
Pete Alonso - Yankees - 6 years/$165M
Roki Sasaki - Dodgers - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Dodgers - 2 years/$16M
Shane Bieber - Brewers - 2 years/$16M
Tanner Scott - Padres - 3 years/$32M
Teoscar Hernández - Orioles - 3 years/$185M
Tyler O'Neill - Royals - 4 years/$55M
Walker Buehler - Nationals - 1 year/$12M
Willy Adames - Dodgers - 4 years/$110M
Yusei Kikuchi - Astros - 3 years/$50M

JJ Phillips @TheOttSpot

Alex Bregman - Astros - 7 years/$200M
Andrew Heaney - Mets - 2 years/$22M
Anthony Santander - Guardians - 4 years/$110M
Blake Snell - Orioles - 5 years/$130M
Carlos Estévez - Yankees - 3 years/$35M
Christian Walker - Astros - 3 years/$60M
Clay Holmes - Red Sox - 3 years/$39M
Corbin Burnes - Dodgers - 7 years/$210M
Frankie Montas - Royals - 4 years/$60M
Gleyber Torres - Mariners - 3 years/$22M
Ha-Seong Kim - Padres - 6 years/$100M
Jack Flaherty - Red Sox - 6 years/$150M
Jeff Hoffman - Rangers - 2 years/$13M
Joc Pederson - Nationals - 3 years/$30M
Juan Soto - Mets - 15 years/$650M
Jurickson Profar - Brewers - 3 years/$25M
Luis Severino - Mets - 3 years/$50M
Max Fried - Blue Jays - 6 years/$140M
Nathan Eovaldi - Reds - 2 years/$50M
Paul Goldschmidt - Diamondbacks - 1 year/$15M
Pete Alonso - Mets - 6 years/$145M
Roki Sasaki - Dodgers - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Mets - 3 years/$55M
Shane Bieber - Nationals - 6 years/$100M
Tanner Scott - Cubs - 3 years/$25M
Teoscar Hernández - Red Sox - 3 years/$80M
Tyler O'Neill - Twins - 4 years/$65M
Walker Buehler - Cardinals - 2 years/$15M
Willy Adames - Dodgers - 7 years/$190M
Yusei Kikuchi - Cubs - 2 years/$30M

L.A. Rice @TalkinNats

Alex Bregman - Astros - 8 years/$180M
Andrew Heaney - Rays - 2 years/$20M
Anthony Santander - Nationals - 5 years/$95M
Blake Snell - Orioles - 5 years/$160M
Carlos Estévez - Phillies - 2 years/$35M
Christian Walker - Nationals - 3 years/$45M
Clay Holmes - Dodgers - 3 years/$35M
Corbin Burnes - Mets - 7 years/$210M
Frankie Montas - Pirates - 2 years/$20M
Gleyber Torres - Mariners - 2 years/$28M
Ha-Seong Kim - Red Sox - 3 years/$30M
Jack Flaherty - Tigers - 4 years/$95M
Jeff Hoffman - Yankees - 3 years/$24M
Joc Pederson - Astros - 2 years/$18M
Juan Soto - Yankees - 14 years/$620M
Jurickson Profar - Padres - 4 years/$60M
Luis Severino - Angels - 3 years/$60M
Max Fried - Braves - 7 years/$190M
Nathan Eovaldi - Orioles - 2 years/$36M
Paul Goldschmidt - Astros - 1 year/$14M
Pete Alonso - Yankees - 6 years/$130M
Roki Sasaki - Dodgers - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Mets - 4 years/$84M
Shane Bieber - Mets - 1 year/$20M
Tanner Scott - Padres - 4 years/$50M
Teoscar Hernández - Dodgers - 4 years/$100M
Tyler O'Neill - Yankees - 2 years/$32M
Walker Buehler - Nationals - 1 year/$16M
Willy Adames - Dodgers - 6 years/$150M
Yusei Kikuchi - Astros - 3 years/$51M

Reese Evans @ReeseEvans99

Alex Bregman - Nationals - 4 years/$120M
Andrew Heaney - Angels - 2 years/$19M
Anthony Santander - Orioles - 5 years/$150M
Blake Snell - Padres - 4 years/$84M
Carlos Estévez - Orioles - 2 years/$28M
Christian Walker - Padres - 3 years/$45M
Clay Holmes - Nationals - 3 years/$33M
Corbin Burnes - Orioles - 7 years/$195M
Frankie Montas - Padres - 2 years/$28M
Gleyber Torres - Yankees - 3 years/$39M
Ha-Seong Kim - Padres - 4 years/$45M
Jack Flaherty - Nationals - 2 years/$24M
Jeff Hoffman - Rockies - 2 years/$11M
Joc Pederson - Cardinals - 3 years/$32M
Juan Soto - Mets - 12 years/$600M
Jurickson Profar - Padres - 4 years/$50M
Luis Severino - Mets - 2 years/$28M
Max Fried - Braves - 7 years/$185M
Nathan Eovaldi - Rangers - 3 years/$50M
Paul Goldschmidt - Yankees - 1 year/$18M
Pete Alonso - Mets - 5 years/$100M
Roki Sasaki - Dodgers - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Mets - 3 years/$45M
Shane Bieber - Astros - 2 years/$20M
Tanner Scott - Dodgers - 2 years/$21M
Teoscar Hernández - Dodgers - 3 years/$75M
Tyler O'Neill - Red Sox - 3 years/$40M
Walker Buehler - Nationals - 2 years/$24M
Willy Adames - Brewers - 4 years/$75M
Yusei Kikuchi - Blue Jays - 3 years/$35M

Sam Holstine @_Sxmurai

Alex Bregman - Astros - 6 years/$138M
Andrew Heaney - Rays - 1 years/$11.5M
Anthony Santander - Orioles - 7 years/$142M
Blake Snell - Orioles - 4 years/$116M
Carlos Estévez - Phillies - 3 years/$35M
Christian Walker - Yankees - 3 years/$42M
Clay Holmes - Padres - 3 years/$39M
Corbin Burnes - Mets - 8 years/$248M
Frankie Montas - Twins - 2 years/$22M
Gleyber Torres - Mariners - 6 years/$86M
Ha-Seong Kim - Giants - 4 years/$58M
Jack Flaherty - Tigers - 4 years/$98M
Jeff Hoffman - Padres - 3 years/$40M
Joc Pederson - Diamondbacks - 3 years/$50M
Juan Soto - Yankees - 14 years/$650M
Jurickson Profar - Brewers - 3 years/$50M
Luis Severino - Nationals - 3 years/$48M
Max Fried - Braves - 7 years/$143M
Nathan Eovaldi - Rangers - 4 years/$68M
Paul Goldschmidt - Cardinals - 2 years/$25M
Pete Alonso - Nationals - 5 years/$105M
Roki Sasaki - Dodgers - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Mets - 4 years/$60M
Shane Bieber - Nationals - 2 years/$35M
Tanner Scott - Yankees - 3 years/$58M
Teoscar Hernández - Dodgers - 4 years/$84M
Tyler O'Neill - Red Sox - 6 years/$90M
Walker Buehler - Braves - 3 years/$33M
Willy Adames - Braves - 4 years/$82M
Yusei Kikuchi - Astros - 4 years/$71M

Stephen Newman @stephen_newman1

Alex Bregman - Astros - 7 years/$210M
Andrew Heaney - Rays - 2 years/$20M
Anthony Santander - Phillies - 4 years/$100M
Blake Snell - Padres - 4 years/$100M
Carlos Estévez - Phillies - 3 years/$36M
Christian Walker - Nationals - 4 years/$72M
Clay Holmes - Dodgers - 3 years/$36M
Corbin Burnes - Mets - 7 years/$210M
Frankie Montas - Twins - 3 years/$33M
Gleyber Torres - Mariners - 3 years/$33M
Ha-Seong Kim - Padres - 4 years/$56M
Jack Flaherty - Tigers - 4 years/$90M
Jeff Hoffman - Rangers - 3 years/$33M
Joc Pederson - Blue Jays - 3 years/$30M
Juan Soto - Yankees - 12 years/$540M
Jurickson Profar - Padres - 3 years/$45M
Luis Severino - Mets - 3 years/$51M
Max Fried - Braves - 6 years/$150M
Nathan Eovaldi - Orioles - 3 years/$60M
Paul Goldschmidt - Diamondbacks - 1 year/$15M
Pete Alonso - Mets - 6 years/$150M
Roki Sasaki - Dodgers - MiLB Contract
Sean Manaea - Yankees - 3 years/$60M
Shane Bieber - Orioles - 2 years/$40M
Tanner Scott - Yankees - 3 years/$42M
Teoscar Hernández - Dodgers - 4 years/$100M
Tyler O'Neill - Red Sox - 4 years/$60M
Walker Buehler - Nationals - 3 years/$36M
Willy Adames - Braves - 5 years/$125M
Yusei Kikuchi - Astros - 3 years/$51M


Positional Breakdown:

Infielders:

Alex Bregman: Nationals (4), Astros (4)
Anthony Santander: Nationals (3), Orioles (2), Phillies (1), Blue Jays (1), Guardians (1)
Christian Walker: Nationals (3), Yankees (2), Diamondbacks (1), Astros (1), Padres (1)
Gleyber Torres: Mariners (6), Blue Jays (1), Yankees (1)
Ha-Seong Kim: Padres (3), Giants (2), Red Sox (1), Yankees (1), Mariners (1)
Paul Goldschmidt: Diamondbacks (3), Astros (2), , Cardinals (2), Yankees (1)
Pete Alonso: Mets (3), Yankees (3), Nationals (1), Mariners (1),
Willy Adames: Braves (3), Dodgers (3), Astros (1), Brewers (1)

Outfielders:

Joc Pederson: Diamondbacks (2), Astros (2), Cardinals (2), Blue Jays (1), Nationals (1)
Juan Soto: Mets (4), Yankees (3), Dodgers (1)
Jurickson Profar: Padres (6), Rockies (1), Brewers (1)
Teoscar Hernandez: Dodgers (5), Red Sox (2), Orioles (1)
Tyler O'Neill: Red Sox (3), Yankees (2), Royals (1), Twins (1) Tigers (1)

Starting Pitchers:

Andrew Heaney: Rays (3), Blue Jays (1), Angels (1), Mets (1) , Nationals (1), Orioles (1)
Blake Snell: Orioles (4), Padres (1), Padres (1), Red Sox (1), Guardians (1)
Corbin Burnes: Mets (4), Orioles (2), Dodgers (1), Yankees (1)
Frankie Montas: Royals (2), Twins (2), Padres (1), Angels (1), Cubs (1), Pirates (1)
Ha-Seong Kim: Padres (3), Giants (2), Yankees (1), Mariners (1), Red Sox (1)
Jack Flaherty: Tigers (4), Astros (1), Padres (1), Red Sox (1), Nationals (1)
Luis Severino: Mets (4), Tigers(2), Nationals (1), Angels (1)
Max Fried: Braves (6), Dodgers (1), Blue Jays (1)
Nathan Eovaldi: Orioles (4), Rangers (3), Reds (1)
Roki Sasaki: Dodgers (4), Padres (3), Cubs (1)
Sean Manaea: Mets (5), Yankees (2), Royals (1)
Shane Bieber: Astros (2), Mets (1), Pirates (1), Brewers (1), Orioles (1), Nationals (1)
Walker Buehler: Nationals (6), Braves (1), Cardinals (1)
Yusei Kikuchi: Astros (4), Cubs (2), Red Sox (1), Blue Jays (1)

Relievers:

Carlos Estevez: Phillies (5), Yankees (2), Orioles (1)
Clay Holmes: Dodgers (2), Rangers(1), Nationals(1), Angels(1), Padres (1), Red Sox (1), Brewers (1)
Jeff Hoffman: Yankees (2), Padres (2), Rangers (2), Phillies (1), Rockies (1)
Tanner Scott: Padres (3), Yankees (2), Cubs (2), Dodgers (1)


manual