Former Nationals clubhouse leader returns to a familiar place

Despite having another year left on his contract, the Nationals decided to part ways with infielder Ildemaro Vargas last month, when they opted against granting him a major league deal. It was likely assumed by most people that they would at least attempt to retain him on a minor league contract, but instead he will be playing elsewhere in 2025.

News broke on Tuesday that Vargas had reached a minor league agreement with the Arizona Diamondbacks, with whom he was a major league contributor from 2017-19, a portion of 2020, and again for part of 2022. As expected, the former team captain in Washington also received an invitation to spring training in Arizona.

He wasn't as essential to the Nationals as other players are, but it's quite possible that his presence will be missed. With that in mind, let's reflect on what he was able to contribute in Washington and ponder whether he was worth keeping around.

Across parts of three seasons in Washington, Vargas batted .257 with eight home runs and 80 RBI in 785 plate appearances, and also stole 13 bases. He logged his most games played (135) at third base, but also often chipped in at second base, shortstop, left field, and even made five pitching appearances.

Although Vargas generally wasn't an everyday starter for the Nationals, he did help them bridge the gap at times after a player had been traded away, or even demoted to the bench or minor leagues. But perhaps more importantly, he seemed to have a vital clubhouse presence as a veteran leader on a young team.

In fact, it would probably be a good idea for the Nationals to sign a similar type of player this offseason, from a leadership perspective. Of course, this could be accomplished by signing one or two of the premier free agents that are available. But even if they don't, adding a cheap veteran would benefit many of the younger players on the roster.

With that said, it's also easy to see why the Nationals may want to lean into their youth movement in the infield. Luis Garcia Jr. firmly established himself as an above average second baseman in 2024, CJ Abrams will return as their everyday shortstop, and even Jose Tena showed plenty of potential at the plate. Nasim Nunez appears to be a viable backup at multiple positions if they choose to keep him up instead of sending him to Triple-A. And of course, Brady House is approaching major-league readiness, at which point he'll presumably become the everyday third baseman.

None of this is to say that the Nationals shouldn't sign a more established veteran. Even putting aside first base, someone like Alex Bregman or even a cheaper option would be a welcome addition to this roster. But even so, perhaps it was time to begin a new chapter that didn't include Ildemaro Vargas.

Of note, Vargas is not the only National to sign a minor league contract elsewhere so far this offseason. Thus far, the list includes relief pitchers Tanner Rainey (Pirates) and Jordan Weems (Braves), along with infielders Joey Meneses (Mets) and Carter Kieboom (Angels). There is perhaps an interesting story to be told surrounding each of these four players as well, and in some cases, we have already. However, opinions seem to be the most split on Vargas.

What do you think? Was it time to move on from Vargas, or should the Nationals have kept him around for another season. As always, you can let me know your thoughts @stephen_newman1.