For the first time since 2023, the Washington Nationals have signed a player to a contract extension. On Friday, the Nationals finalized a deal with ace right-hander Cade Cavalli for 4 years and potentially up to $70 million if the team option in 2031 is exercised. In short, it will keep the righty under the Nationals' control for the next 5 seasons, and if he can continue this level of output it will be a bargain.
It's been a long time since a player has signed an extension with Washington -- the last was Keibert Ruiz in March of 2023. While this may not seem that long ago, the Nats' opening day lineup just weeks after included Joey Meneses, Dom Smith, Jeimer Candelario, Patrick Corbin, Kyle Finnegan, and Victor Robles.
We're talking a completely different era of Nationals baseball here -- then again, not much has changed since, in terms of winning at least.
Anyway, Nationals fans know all too well that Mark Lerner hasn't exactly opened his checkbook to players since 2019, signing Stephen Strasburg to a massive 7-year, $245 million deal after winning the world series. Sure, that contract play out well, but there's not much anyone could've done about that.
Since then? Crickets. Nothing. From 2022 until now, Washington has ranked in the bottom-third of baseball in player payroll -- and the fans suffered because of it. Four straight 91+ loss seasons mired by low attendance, and even lower payroll.
My point here is this -- for many franchises, extensions for young players are almost expected -- given, counted on, and unsurprising. For the Nats in 2026? A breath of cool, crisp, and fresh air.
So, now with Cavalli under contract for the foreseeable future, who's next? Does Paul Toboni have Mark Lerner's blessing to extend more of the team's young talent? Spend in free agency? The latter is topic for the winter, however long it may be. Let's focus on the former: which young National could be next in line for an extension? If you ask me...
Daylen Lile should be the next player to be extended by the Nationals
Lile probably isn't the first candidate to come to your mind -- understandably. He's not the All-Star(s) of the team -- that's James Wood and CJ Abrams. Why wouldn't it be them?
Let's start with Wood. James Wood is a client of Scott Boras, of the Boras Corporation. Boras has a reputation focused solely on netting maximum dollar value for his clients, not caring much for hometown hero stories or home-grown discounts -- loyalty doesn't seem to mean much to him.
The statistics are staggering -- in the last five years, twenty players represented by Boras have signed deals higher than $10M average annual value -- and only three of those players re-signed to the team that they most recently played for (Bellinger, Nimmo, and Correa).
An even more fascinating note is this -- a player represented by Boras has never signed a pre-arbitration contract extension with the club that they debuted with. Ever. If James Wood were to sign an extension with the Washington Nationals right now, he would be the first to ever do it. As crazy as that seems, that's just the way Boras operates.
With that in mind, we can safely take Wood off the table. What about Abrams?
CJ Abrams is represented by Roc Nation Sports, who also represents Fernando Tatis Jr., Jesus Luzardo, Jazz Chisholm Jr., and Harry Ford among others.
Abrams' case is hardly about representation, but his future with the franchise. Not currently on the trade block, his move to second base at the end of this season has created a rather awkward conversation about where CJ fits into Washington's plans over the next few seasons. With Abrams' defense at short leaving enough to be desired, and #1 prospect Eli Willits earning a promotion to Double-A, question marks surround.
If CJ Abrams and Paul Toboni can come to an agreement about his place in the Nationals' lineup for the future, all the above considered, sure, an extension could happen. But for now, I'd be willing to wager that there won't be an extension for Abrams any time soon, if ever.
That brings us to Daylen Lile
Washington's leader in games played, plate appearances, and triples in 2026 has solidified himself as a key part of Washington's outfield for years to come. He's top three in pretty much every other offensive categories: hits, home runs, RBIs, and runs scored, just to name a few.
Lile is one of only two current Nationals with over 600 plate appearances carrying an average of .250 or better (CJ Abrams is the other, James Wood projects to get there). And in case you weren't aware, Lile will finish this season at only 23 years old. Even add in the fact that there have already been some slight rumors flying around that a Lile extension could be in the works, and it seems more likely.
With the uncertainty around the development of Dylan Crews, and the revamped farm system focusing more on infield talent, Lile has seemingly locked up his spot in the outfield next to James Wood for years to come.
What could an extension look like?
Extensions for players Lile's age with his achievement in the major leagues have happened before. In the last four years, these deals have been signed:
Ceddanne Rafaela, Red Sox -- 8 years, $50 million
Lawrence Butler, Athletics -- 7 years, $65.5 million
Jackson Chourio, Brewers -- 8 years, $82 million
Corbin Carroll, Diamondbacks -- 8 years, $111 million
Michael Harris, Braves -- 8 years, $72 million
Now, Lile isn't as touted a prospect as the likes of Carroll and Chourio, I think any extension with Washington could follow a similar length -- 8 years seems pretty standard, to buy out any remaining pre-arb years.
Dollar value is the variable -- top prospects such as the above, and even those signed recently of those who had yet to debut (Colt Emerson, Mariners) can reach $100 million or more. However, I wouldn't expect Lile to surpass nine figures. A solid contributor, the upside doesn't appear as high as those of other franchises' top prospects.
I would wager that if Daylen Lile signs a contract extension with Washington, it would likely fall between 6-8 years, and $50-$70 million dollars. This would put him in the range of guys like Rafaela, Butler, and Harris, which feels a little bit closer to his value at this particular point in time.
Modest dollar value on a long term deal for Lile, who has shown his fit with the Nationals is more than just a one-hit wonder.
Do you think Lile will be the next to extend? Let me know in the comments, or @andrewpindc.
Add us as a preferred source on Google